This week’s reading of Confederates in the Attic brings up the issue of commercialization and preservation of historical sites. Chapter 10 of this book is titled “The Civil Wargasm” and chronicles the trip author Tony Horwitz makes with his friend and reenactor aficionado, Robert Lee Hodge, to various Civil War battle sites and other places of notability throughout Virginia and Maryland. The chapter held a lot of informational and educational tidbits about the Civil War, but in between the historical aspects were the glimpses of the effects of commercialization and commentary on social class. During their trip, which lasted only a few days, they found that many of the battle grounds they sought to see had been covered by strip malls, golf courses, housing developments, and other signs of the modern era.
I think it really goes back to what we have discussed in the archives; historians have to make decisions about what is worth preserving and what can be thrown away or, in this case, bulldozed over. The consideration of stakeholders is really important in these cases but sometimes it can be difficult to appease all stakeholders. Big businesses and the local community are equally important stakeholders. One could argue that the local community is actually more important because they could have emotional and familial connections to the historic events that occurred in the town. However, the sad fact is that big businesses have more money, power and sway when it comes to the buying of land. Readers see in the chapter how communities that once flourished had fallen into decay and poverty due to the takeover of big businesses.
For example, one of the people Horwitz and Hodge met during their trip was Jimmy Olgers, the owner of Olgers Store which was a general store turned museum. The store was built by his grandfather at the turn of the 19th century and was forced to close after eighty years of operation when stores like Walmart and Kmart began to be built in the town. After the store closed, Olgers reopened it as a museum containing everything from the supposed “largest pair of bloomers in the world, worn by Bertha Magoo” to a large statue of Robert E. Lee constructed out of junk scraps. (Horwitz p. 260) Olgers works multiple jobs besides being the “storekeeper”, including a job at a funeral parlor and serving as unofficial mayor, to make ends meet. His story is an interesting case of the birth of a public history site and the death of a generational business at the hands of corporate America.